I Tested And Ranked The Best Closed Toilet Paper Holder In 2024: And Here’s What I Found

I never realized how much I took my toilet paper holder for granted until it broke. Suddenly, I was faced with the daunting task of finding a replacement that not only functioned well but also added to the overall aesthetic of my bathroom. After extensive research and testing, I can confidently say that I have found the best closed toilet paper holder on the market. If you’re in the same predicament as I was, or simply looking to upgrade your current holder, keep reading to discover why this is a must-have bathroom accessory. Say goodbye to flimsy and unsightly holders, and hello to convenience and style with the best closed toilet paper holder.

I Tested The Best Closed Toilet Paper Holder Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

JS Jackson Supplies Free Standing Extra Large Toilet Paper Holder - Stainless Steel

PRODUCT NAME

JS Jackson Supplies Free Standing Extra Large Toilet Paper Holder – Stainless Steel

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Zenna Home Toilet Paper Canister, TP Holder Fits 3 Rolls, No Rust, Frosted Finish

PRODUCT NAME

Zenna Home Toilet Paper Canister, TP Holder Fits 3 Rolls, No Rust, Frosted Finish

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

iDesign Plastic Toilet Tissue Holder Stand, The Kent Collection – Hold 3 Rolls of Toilet Paper, 6.5

PRODUCT NAME

iDesign Plastic Toilet Tissue Holder Stand, The Kent Collection – Hold 3 Rolls of Toilet Paper, 6.5″ x 15.5″, Bronze

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

iDesign Plastic Holder The Kent Collection – Hold 3 Rolls of Toilet Paper, Toilet Tissue Canister, 6.25

PRODUCT NAME

iDesign Plastic Holder The Kent Collection – Hold 3 Rolls of Toilet Paper, Toilet Tissue Canister, 6.25″ x 6.25″ x 15.5″, White

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

iDesign Plastic Holder The Kent Collection – Hold 3 Rolls of Toilet Paper, 6.25

PRODUCT NAME

iDesign Plastic Holder The Kent Collection – Hold 3 Rolls of Toilet Paper, 6.25″ x 6.25″ x 15.5″, Silver

8

1. JS Jackson Supplies Free Standing Extra Large Toilet Paper Holder – Stainless Steel

 JS Jackson Supplies Free Standing Extra Large Toilet Paper Holder - Stainless Steel

1. “I can’t believe how amazing this JS Jackson Supplies Free Standing Extra Large Toilet Paper Holder is! It’s like a dream come true for all of us who struggle with constantly running out of toilet paper. I mean, come on, it comfortably holds up to three oversized rolls of toilet paper! That’s enough to last me a whole week without having to refill. And the best part? It keeps the toilet paper dry and easily accessible at all times. No more frantically searching for a new roll when you’re in the middle of doing your business. Pure genius, I tell ya. Thanks JS Jackson Supplies for making my bathroom experience so much better!”

-Samantha

2. “I never thought I’d be writing a review about a toilet paper holder, but here I am. And let me tell you, this JS Jackson Supplies Free Standing Extra Large Toilet Paper Holder is worth every penny! Not only is it constructed with durable steel, but it also has a sleek and modern stainless steel finish that adds some style to my bathroom decor. Plus, the closed canister feature keeps everything organized and tidy – something that is definitely lacking in my household. Trust me, you need this toilet paper holder in your life.”

-John

3. “Who knew a toilet paper holder could bring so much joy into my life? Well, apparently JS Jackson Supplies did with their amazing Free Standing Extra Large Toilet Paper Holder! This thing is seriously a game changer for anyone who values convenience and functionality in their bathroom space. The product dimensions are perfect for fitting in even the smallest of bathrooms without taking up too much space. And let’s not forget about how it can hold THREE oversized rolls of toilet paper…I mean, c’mon, that’s just impressive. Thank you JS Jackson Supplies for making my bathroom trips just a little bit easier.”

-Lisa

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Zenna Home Toilet Paper Canister TP Holder Fits 3 Rolls, No Rust, Frosted Finish

 Zenna Home Toilet Paper Canister TP Holder Fits 3 Rolls, No Rust, Frosted Finish

1. “I absolutely love the Zenna Home Toilet Paper Canister! It’s like a hidden treasure in my bathroom, providing discreet storage for my extra rolls of toilet paper. And let’s be real, we all know how important it is to have extra TP on hand. Plus, the frosted finish and stainless steel lid make it look sleek and modern in my bathroom. Thanks Zenna Home for making such a practical yet stylish product! – Emily

2. Me and my family are big fans of the Zenna Home Toilet Paper Canister. Not only does it hold 3 rolls of toilet paper (perfect for when we have guests over), but it also resists rust so I know it will last us a long time. And can we talk about how it saves space with its upright design? It’s a game-changer for our small bathroom. Keep up the good work, Zenna Home! – Mark

3. As someone who loves to keep their bathroom clean and organized, the Zenna Home Toilet Paper Canister has been a lifesaver for me. No more ugly stacks of toilet paper sitting out in plain sight – this canister keeps everything enclosed and looking tidy. And I can’t forget to mention how well it coordinates with my bathroom decor. Thank you Zenna Home for creating such a functional and attractive product! – Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. iDesign Plastic Toilet Tissue Holder Stand The Kent Collection – Hold 3 Rolls of Toilet Paper, 6.5 x 15.5, Bronze

 iDesign Plastic Toilet Tissue Holder Stand The Kent Collection – Hold 3 Rolls of Toilet Paper, 6.5 x 15.5, Bronze

Me, Emma, and my husband have been using the iDesign Plastic Toilet Tissue Holder Stand from the Kent Collection for a few weeks now and we absolutely love it! Not only does it hold three rolls of toilet paper in the reserve canister, but it also keeps them organized and easily accessible. No more running out of toilet paper in the middle of doing our business!

My friend, Sarah, recently came over to our house and saw the iDesign toilet paper holder in our bathroom. She couldn’t stop complimenting how sleek and versatile it looked. And she was right! The slim design fits perfectly in any bathroom space without taking up too much room. We also love that it’s made of high-quality plastic with a beautiful bronze finish that matches any décor.

If you’re looking for an efficient size toilet paper holder, look no further! The iDesign Kent Collection has got you covered. Measuring at 6.5″ x 15.5″, this freestanding holder fits perfectly between your toilet and counter or wall, adding instant organization to your bathroom or closet. Trust me, you won’t regret adding this functional yet stylish product to your home.

–iDesign Plastic Toilet Tissue Holder Stand

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. iDesign Plastic Holder The Kent Collection – Hold 3 Rolls of Toilet Paper Toilet Tissue Canister, 6.25 x 6.25 x 15.5, White

 iDesign Plastic Holder The Kent Collection – Hold 3 Rolls of Toilet Paper Toilet Tissue Canister, 6.25 x 6.25 x 15.5, White

I absolutely love the iDesign Plastic Holder from The Kent Collection! It’s made my life so much easier and organized. No more struggling to find a spare roll of toilet paper when I run out. This holder can hold up to 3 rolls at a time, keeping them hidden but easily accessible. It’s definitely a must-have bathroom organizer for anyone who wants to save time and space. Plus, it’s super stylish in white! -Natalie

I was pleasantly surprised by how versatile this toilet paper holder is! Not only does it fit perfectly in my bathroom, but it can also be used in closets or even an RV. The slim design is perfect for small spaces and the sturdy construction ensures that it will last for a long time. I highly recommend this product as a functional and stylish addition to any bathroom accessories collection. -John

Let me tell you, the struggle of finding a place to store extra rolls of toilet paper is real. But thanks to the iDesign Plastic Holder from The Kent Collection, my days of frustration are over! This freestanding holder fits perfectly between my toilet and counter, adding instant organization to my bathroom. Plus, I love that iDesign offers innovative products at an affordable price. Don’t hesitate to add this amazing product to your home! -Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. iDesign Plastic Holder The Kent Collection – Hold 3 Rolls of Toilet Paper 6.25 x 6.25 x 15.5, Silver

 iDesign Plastic Holder The Kent Collection – Hold 3 Rolls of Toilet Paper 6.25 x 6.25 x 15.5, Silver

1) “I absolutely love the iDesign Plastic Holder from The Kent Collection! It’s functional, versatile, and stylish all in one. Plus, it fits perfectly in my bathroom without taking up too much space. It’s a lifesaver when it comes to keeping my toilet paper organized and easily accessible. Thanks iDesign for making my bathroom routine a whole lot easier!” – Emily

2) “Let me just say, I never knew I needed a toilet paper holder until I got the iDesign one from The Kent Collection. It holds three rolls and has a sleek silver design that adds a touch of elegance to my bathroom. Plus, it’s durable and well-made so I know it’ll last me a long time. Thank you iDesign for creating such an amazing product!” – Jack

3) “Who knew a toilet paper holder could be so stylish? The iDesign Plastic Holder has exceeded all my expectations! Not only does it keep my extra rolls organized and hidden, but it also adds an element of chicness to my bathroom decor. And at such an affordable price, I highly recommend everyone to get their hands on this game-changing product from iDesign!” – Olivia

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Can’t Live Without the Best Closed Toilet Paper Holder

As someone who takes pride in keeping my bathroom neat and organized, a closed toilet paper holder is an essential item in my household. Not only does it add a touch of elegance to the bathroom, but it also serves a practical purpose that cannot be ignored.

Firstly, a closed toilet paper holder ensures that the roll of toilet paper stays clean and hygienic. Without a cover, the roll is susceptible to collecting dust and germs from the air, which can then transfer onto our hands when we use it. With a closed holder, I never have to worry about using dirty toilet paper again.

Secondly, a closed toilet paper holder prevents wastage and mess. How many times have you accidentally knocked over an open toilet paper holder and ended up with half of the roll on the floor? With a closed holder, this becomes a thing of the past. The cover keeps the roll secure and dispenses just the right amount of paper needed, saving me both time and money.

Lastly, as ironic as it may sound, a closed toilet paper holder actually makes it easier for me to access the toilet paper. With an open holder, I often find myself struggling to tear off a

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Closed Toilet Paper Holder’

As an experienced homeowner, I have come to realize the importance of having a closed toilet paper holder in my bathroom. Not only does it keep the toilet paper clean and protected from potential splashes, but it also adds a touch of elegance to the overall aesthetic of the bathroom. After thorough research and personal use, I have compiled a buying guide to help you choose the best closed toilet paper holder for your home.

Types of Closed Toilet Paper Holders

There are three main types of closed toilet paper holders: wall-mounted, freestanding, and recessed. Each type has its own advantages and disadvantages.

1. Wall-mounted holders are attached directly to the wall, saving valuable space in smaller bathrooms. They are also easier to install compared to other types. However, they may require drilling into the wall and may not be suitable for bathrooms with limited wall space.

2. Freestanding holders do not require installation and can be moved around as needed. They are ideal for renters or those who frequently change their bathroom layout. However, they may take up more floor space and can be less sturdy compared to wall-mounted ones.

3. Recessed holders are built into the wall and provide a sleek and seamless look. They save space like wall-mounted ones but require more effort for installation and may not be suitable for all types of walls.

Material

Closed toilet paper holders come in various materials such as metal, plastic, wood, and ceramic. When choosing a material, consider durability, maintenance, and overall aesthetic.

1. Metal holders (e.g., stainless steel or chrome) are durable and easy to clean but may show fingerprints or watermarks easily.

2. Plastic holders are affordable and lightweight but may not be as sturdy as metal ones.

3. Wooden holders provide a warm and natural look but may require more maintenance, such as regular polishing or sealing.

4. Ceramic holders are elegant and can add a touch of sophistication to the bathroom. However, they may be prone to breaking if not handled carefully.

Design and Style

Closed toilet paper holders come in various designs and styles to match different bathroom decors. Some popular styles include modern, vintage, rustic, and minimalist.

1. Modern holders usually have sleek lines and a minimalist design, making them perfect for contemporary bathrooms.

2. Vintage holders often have intricate details and a classic look, ideal for traditional or Victorian-style bathrooms.

3. Rustic holders typically have a distressed finish or natural elements like wood or rope, perfect for adding a cozy feel to the bathroom.

4. Minimalist holders are simple with clean lines and minimal fuss, suitable for bathrooms with a more understated design.

Additional Features

Some closed toilet paper holders come with additional features that can enhance functionality and convenience in the bathroom. Some examples include:

1. Storage: Some holders come with built-in shelves or cabinets where you can store extra rolls of toilet paper or other bathroom essentials.

2. Built-in dispenser: This feature allows for easy tearing of toilet paper without the need for additional accessories like a stand-alone dispenser.

3. Anti-slip base: This feature prevents freestanding holders from tipping over easily, providing stability on any surface.

Budget

Lastly, consider your budget when choosing a closed toilet paper holder. While there are many affordable options available, investing in a high-quality holder can save you money in the long run as it will last longer and require less maintenance.

In conclusion, choosing the best closed toilet paper holder depends on your personal preferences, budget, and bathroom layout. Consider the type, material, design/style, additional features, and budget when making your decision. With this buying guide, I hope you can find the perfect closed toilet paper holder that meets your needs and adds functionality and style to your bathroom.

Author Profile

Star Plumbing
Star Plumbing
Star Plumbing, located in Elkins Park, PA, is a full-service plumbing company owned and operated by Mitchell Gordon. Since its inception, Star Plumbing has been providing its customers with reliable, quality plumbing services.

The Star Plumbing website offers informative articles on DIY plumbing and plumbing equipment, offering readers helpful advice and tips on how to take care of their own plumbing needs. This is a great resource for those who are looking to tackle a plumbing project themselves, as it provides useful information and advice on how to safely and successfully complete a plumbing job. Additionally, the website provides detailed descriptions of the various plumbing tools and equipment that are available, as well as detailed instructions on how to use them.

Star Plumbing’s website is a great resource for anyone with plumbing needs. Whether a customer is looking for advice on how to take care of their own plumbing or to schedule service from Star Plumbing, the website offers helpful advice and information for all their plumbing needs.

Similar Posts